Cleverly Warns Labour’s Plan to Scrap Newspaper Licensing Ads Threatens Local Democracy

Home Secretary Sir James Cleverly has accused Labour of putting local democracy at risk with proposals to remove requirements for businesses to publish licensing notices in newspapers, warning the move could devastate both the hospitality sector and regional journalism.

In a letter to Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, Cleverly said Labour’s plan to eliminate statutory notices—which mandate pubs, restaurants, and clubs to advertise licensing applications in local papers—was drafted “without any consideration” for its impact on press freedom or public transparency.

Key Concerns Over Labour’s Proposal

• Threat to Local Journalism: Removing this revenue stream could push struggling regional newspapers closer to collapse.
• Weakened Public Oversight: Communities may lose a critical channel for learning about licensing changes affecting their neighborhoods.
• Unintended Consequences for Businesses: Cleverly argued the changes might “make it harder for many pubs and clubs to operate” by reducing visibility of their applications.

Labour’s Justification

Chancellor Rachel Reeves framed the move as a “cut to bureaucratic red tape” for the hospitality sector, telling the Mail on Sunday the rule requiring print ads was “outdated.” The proposal aligns with broader plans to streamline licensing, including faster approvals for outdoor dining.

Industry Backlash

The News Media Association (NMA) condemned the idea as a “betrayal of local communities,” warning:

• Public Disenfranchisement: Fewer residents would be aware of licensing changes.
• Financial Blow to Papers: Statutory notices provide a vital income source for local journalism.

NMA CEO Owen Meredith said: “Local pubs, like local papers, are community pillars. This plan helps neither—it’s an assault on democratic engagement.”

Cleverly’s Democratic Warning

The Home Secretary emphasized that “local democracy needs an independent free press” to hold leaders accountable. He urged Labour to disclose its impact assessments, questioning:

• How will the public stay informed without newspaper notices?
• What alternatives exist to ensure transparency?

Broader Context

The clash reflects a wider debate over balancing business efficiency with civic accountability. While Labour aims to reduce burdens for venues, critics argue the policy risks sacrificing public oversight for expediency.

Government’s Stance?
No official response yet, but the controversy highlights tensions between deregulation and democratic safeguards.

---

Why This Matters

• Local Journalism Crisis: Over 300 UK newspapers have closed since 2009; losing statutory notices could accelerate the decline.
• Community Impact: Fewer newspapers mean less scrutiny of local government and businesses.
• Hospitality Industry: Will the changes actually help pubs, or just obscure their licensing bids?

Final Thought:
As Labour pushes modernization, can it avoid undermining the very institutions that sustain grassroots democracy?